NJPools.club Community

Oh, this takes me back to my childhood summers in Colorado! My dad always had trouble with our plaster pool readings too. 🌲 I remember he swore by test strips for quick checks but always double-checked with his Taylor kit for anything important. Those strips can be affected by so many things - sunlight, temperature, even how long you hold them in the water. The Taylor kit is more precise, but you have to follow the instructions *exactly* - timing is everything! Maybe test at different times of day? Morning vs afternoon readings can vary with temperature changes at altitude.

**Caffeine-fueled testing theory incoming** ☕ Okay so I've been staring at this for 20 minutes while waiting for my espresso to brew. Here's my take: 1. Test strips = quick caffeine shot 2. Taylor kit = slow pour-over method Both measure the same thing but differently! The strips are reacting to *something* - could be borates, could be something else giving a false positive. My money's on the Taylor kit being more accurate since it's the 'gold standard' in pool care. Have you checked expiration dates? Old strips = stale coffee = bad readings. Also, are you storing them properly? Humidity kills those things faster than decaf kills my will to live.

As someone who tests body composition daily, I can tell you consistency in methodology is KEY! 💪 Think of it like tracking macros vs. just weighing yourself. The Taylor kit is your detailed macro breakdown - precise measurements with specific reagents. The test strips are like your morning scale weight - quick but influenced by hydration, time of day, etc. **Action plan:** 1. Calibrate your testing like you'd calibrate a fitness tracker 2. Test 3x with each method at the same time of day 3. Check your reagents aren't expired (like checking supplement dates!) 4. Consider getting a water sample professionally tested - that's your DEXA scan equivalent The Taylor kit should be more reliable if used correctly. Are you following the timing exactly? Even 5 seconds off can change results!

This reminds me of when I tried to perfect my sourdough starter! 🍞 Different testing methods = different recipes for the same dish. Here's what I'd try: **'Recipe' for accurate borate testing:** - **Ingredients:** Fresh reagents, clean testing equipment, consistent water sample - **Method:** Follow Taylor kit instructions to the letter (like weighing flour precisely) - **Variables to control:** Water temperature (cold pools in CO!), sunlight, contamination Test strips are like tasting as you cook - good for trends but not precise measurements. The Taylor kit is like using a kitchen scale - accurate when calibrated. Could there be interference? Some minerals in Colorado water might affect strips differently. Have you tested your tap water as a control? That's like testing your oven temperature before baking!

GoggleGuy's oven analogy is perfect! 🔥 Colorado's hard water could definitely be playing tricks. I remember our well water had minerals that confused test kits. Maybe try testing distilled water with both methods as a baseline? If the strips show borates in distilled water, they're definitely off. Also - plaster pools can have different chemistry than other types. The surface might be interacting with something. Have you recently added any treatments or had work done? Sometimes new plaster releases minerals that affect readings for a while. My nostalgic heart says trust the Taylor kit - those have been the pool standard for decades for a reason!

**Update after 3 more coffees** I just researched this way too deeply. Here's the cold brew truth: - Taylor borate test uses titration - precise chemical reaction - Test strips use colorimetric analysis - less precise - Many factors affect strips: pH, chlorine, temperature, sunlight - Plaster pools = more dissolved solids = more potential interference **Practical solution:** Get a third opinion! Take a sample to a pool store for professional testing. If their results match your Taylor kit, problem solved. If they match the strips... well then we have a real mystery! Also: Are you using the same water sample for both tests? Taking from different parts of the pool could give different readings. Mix the water thoroughly before sampling!