NJPools.club Community

Hey everyone, I've been researching mineral systems for my pool here in Oregon and I'm torn. The biohacker in me loves the idea of using copper and silver ions to control bacteria and algae - it's a more natural approach than dumping chlorine constantly. But I've read horror stories about copper staining on plaster and even some vinyl liners. Has anyone found a way to balance the antimicrobial benefits with stain prevention? Maybe through precise dosing or water testing protocols?

**FilterFan31** - I'm with you on the natural approach! As someone who's all about optimizing systems (whether it's my Crossfit WOD or my home), mineral systems seem like an elegant solution. The reduced chlorine exposure is a huge plus for skin and respiratory health. But here's my take: you need to treat it like any other optimization problem. Monitor your pH religiously (keep it between 7.2-7.6), use sequestering agents specifically designed for metals, and consider a hybrid approach - minimal chlorine supplemented with minerals. The staining risk is real, but manageable with discipline.

Interesting discussion! Coming at this from a chef's perspective, I think about water quality like I think about ingredients. Copper can be great in trace amounts (we use copper cookware for a reason!), but too much ruins everything. My neighbor here in Oregon had terrible blue-green stains on his plaster pool from a mineral system gone wrong. I've been experimenting with a different approach: I use a mineral cartridge at the lower end of the recommended range, combined with weekly shocking and a good enzyme treatment. It's like seasoning food - you can always add more, but you can't take it out once it's there. Regular testing is non-negotiable.

**LadderLord** - Love the systematic approach! What specific sequestering agents have you had success with? I've been looking at HEDP-based products. **GoggleGuy** - The cooking analogy is perfect. That's exactly my concern - the irreversible nature of staining. Have you found that the enzyme treatment helps break down organic matter enough to reduce the mineral system's workload? I'm wondering if we're overcomplicating this - maybe just using minerals during peak swim season and switching to traditional methods in winter?

**FilterFan31** - I use a phosphonate-based sequestrant (yes, HEDP is in that family) every month during swimming season. It's part of my maintenance "routine" - just like foam rolling after workouts. As for seasonal switching: that's smart optimization! I run my mineral system April-October here in Oregon, then winterize with a chlorine shock and cover. The key metrics I track: copper levels (keep below 0.3 ppm), pH, and total alkalinity. It's more work upfront, but the water feels amazing and my family isn't breathing chlorine fumes all summer.

**FilterFan31** - Enzymes definitely help! They break down oils, lotions, and other organics that would otherwise bind to the copper ions and increase staining risk. Think of it like deglazing a pan before making a sauce - you're removing the stuff that would burn and stick. I agree with **LadderLord** on the 0.3 ppm copper limit. One more tip from the kitchen: if you do get light staining, ascorbic acid (vitamin C) treatments can sometimes lift copper stains, similar to how acid helps clean copper pans. But prevention through testing is way better than cure!